19 Nov Describe the strategic economic questions all firms must answer. Appraise various?objectives and economic data needed for an industry analysis from the at
Describe the strategic economic questions all firms must answer. Appraise various objectives and economic data needed for an industry analysis from the attached form.
- Investigate the economic data in order to determine the competitive environment of an industry.
- Interpret economic data in order to create an economic forecast for an industry.
- Determine opportunities and risks within the economic analysis.
- Critique the economic decision-making process of organizations within an industry for alignment with the VBM.
For the agricultural market you chose in the previous workshop, what are some current and future opportunities and risks for the next five to ten years? How might a manager in this market address both the positive and negative risks? What might a manager do differently if he or she practiced VBM?
Find a generative artificial intelligence program online and input this query, "What are some current and future opportunities and risks for the next five to ten years in the [market you chose] market? How might a manager in this market address both the positive and negative risks? How might a virtuous manager in this market address both the positive and negative risks?"
- Some of the better known AI platforms are Viso Suite, ChatGPT, Jupyter Notebooks, and Google Cloud AI. Or you could submit your own Google search for an alternative AI platform.
- How to cite AI(new tab) with The American Psychological Association
McAdoo, T. (2024, February 23). How to cite ChatGPT. APA Style Blog. https://apastyle.apa.org/blog/how-to-cite-chatgpt. - How to cite AI(new tab) with Purdue University
Purdue University Libraries and School of Information Studies. (nd). How to Cite AI-Generated Content. LibGuide. https://guides.lib.purdue.edu/c.php?g=1371380&p=10135074.
- How to cite AI(new tab) with The American Psychological Association
- Scan how the AI's response is similar or different from your own response. Were you surprised by anything in the AI generated response?
1
6
Agricultural Industry – Dairy Market
Based upon your investigation of the agricultural industry thus far, choose a specific agricultural market and describe the competitive environment at each stage in the supply chain (the suppliers of feed and other inputs, the individual farmer, the aggregator of the farm output, the food manufacturer, and the final consumer.)
The dairy industry represents a compelling example of the wide variance of market structure through the stages of the agricultural supply chain and the implications of value-based (VBM) management decision-making. The cattle feed market at the input level is characteristic of monopolistic competition, with many regional suppliers offering differentiated products such as specialized feed mixes, supplements, and hay (Mikhalkina et al., 2015). The basis for this determination is the existence of many suppliers, low barriers to entry, and product differentiation through nutritional content and quality factors. This VBM effort becomes even more critical for feed suppliers as this is a competitive market, and they must focus on product innovation and building strong relations with farmers to capture value.
At the level of the individual dairy farmer, the market structure adopts its form closer to perfect competition. The support for this assessment comes from many small to medium dairy operations producing essentially homogeneous raw milk and little power to influence market prices (Mikhalkina et al., 2015). Farmers share this characteristic regarding production technology, costs, and quality standards, while there is widespread market information on milk prices. From a VBM perspective, this implies that if dairy farmers are to generate returns above their cost of capital, they must be excellent at operational efficiency and cost management because they have little pricing power.
At the aggregator level, an oligopolistic market structure is exhibited, dominated by dairy cooperatives and processors. The presence of a few large players in a region collecting, processing, and distributing raw milk counts for this determination (Mikhalkina et al., 2015). Capital requirements for processing facilities and distribution networks are high enough to serve as barriers to entry. The VBM angle on this market structure implies that aggregators can generate value by leveraging economies of scale, optimizing collection routes, and placing themselves in high-value markets.
The stage's food manufacturing side also manifests oligopoly characteristics, with a few large dairy companies controlling most of the branded dairy manufacturing (Bolotova, 2024). The observed behavior by significant players in the market and the investment in the processing facilities, brand development, and distribution networks support this assessment. This market structure suggests that manufacturers should advance their brand premium development, product innovation, and efficient capacity utilization to support VBM in this market.
The consumer market for dairy products is monopolistic competition, with many brands competing per product differentiation, packaging, and marketing (Bolotova, 2024). The basis of this determination is the rich availability of products, brand loyalty factors, and the firm's ability to exercise some pricing power in differentiation. Understanding this market structure from a VBM perspective would mean investing in developing brands, products, and marketing capabilities, which is essential to capturing consumer value.
How did you make your determination of market structure in each of these stages?
Four vital economic criteria, the number of firms, barriers to entry, product differentiation, and price control, were used to determine market structures throughout the dairy supply chain (Bolotova, 2024). For instance, perfect competition was found at the farm level since it is estimated that numerous small producers are producing homogeneous products (raw milk), taking price for granted, and there is also a low entry barrier other than initial capital investment (Bolotova, 2024). Differently, the dairy processor’s oligopolistic structure was determined by identifying a few dominant firms. This high capital requirement acts as an entry barrier, as well as significant market power and the ability to affect the price. The market structure classification of each stage was systematically evaluated against these criteria.
From a VBM perspective, how might understanding the market structure affect decision-making?
The structure of a market, as viewed through a VBM lens, directly impacts strategic decision-making by pointing out where and how sustainability value can be created. When evaluating VBM in perfectly competitive markets such as farming, the decision should solely consider operational efficiency and cost management for returns above investment costs. In processing (oligopoly) markets, firms can create value through economies of scale, brand development, and strategic pricing. Market structure analysis allows managers to determine the optimal capital allocation strategy, i.e., whether to reduce costs in competitive markets or invest in brand building in differentiated markets. With this understanding, investment decisions are made consistent with the firm’s value capture and sustainability ability.
Prompt from AI
As I did, the AI identified the dairy supply chain stages and the corresponding market structures, like monopolistic competition for feed supply, perfect competition at the farmer level, oligopoly for aggregators and manufacturers, or monopolistic competition for consumer products. Responses used criteria such as barriers to entry, firm numbers, product differentiation, and pricing power to determine market structures. The AI's explanation was slightly more generalized, allowing for less details on how the VBM principle applies in each stage concerning brand development and operational efficiency. I was a bit surprised that the AI did not drill down into specific strategies per each market stage as much as I did, especially for farmers and aggregators. The resulting AI summarization of supply chain stages was generally good, but my response on the VBM implications was broader.
References
Bolotova, Y. V. (2024). Private Supply Management and Market Power in the US Dairy Industry. Journal of Agricultural & Food Industrial Organization, 22(1), 1-17.
Mikhalkina, E., Maitah, M., & Srédl, K. (2015). Measuring market structures in the dairy market in the Czech Republic. Asian Social Science, 11(21), 306.
