In this module, we considered the role of theory in the policy analysis process. In particular, "theory" might refer to conceptual logic linking programming implementation to outcome; or it could refer to the more academic, formal theories of crime causation and correlates, which stand to inform crime prevention and response. Mears discusses examples involving supermax prisons and faith-based reentry programs to illustrate his perspective.

In this week's discussion, I'd like to hear your perspective about the role of theory in criminal justice policy. Why do you think criminal justice policies frequently lack clear or defensible theoretical foundations? What are the costs and benefits of maintaining this largely atheoretical policy landscape? Would you, given your education and experience with criminal justice issues, support a shift?