3. In Judith Thomson’s article on abortion she uses several analogies to prove her point. Give three of her analogies and explain what they are used to show. ( 400 words in 5 hours)

4. In Hardin’s article, Living on a Lifeboat, he argues against both foreign food aid and permissive immigration policies. Explain his positions. From and environmentalist’s perspective is there a basic contradiction between environmentalism and humanitarianism? If you agree with Hardin, as a policymaker, how would you “sell” his views? If you disagree with him, how would you avoid some of the “inhumane” options he suggests. (400 words in 5 hours )